Introduction
The topic of genocide against
the Hutu is complex and often debated in academic and political circles. The
most well-documented mass killings in Rwanda's history are the 1994 Rwandan
Genocide, in which an estimated 800,000 to 1,000,000 Tutsi and moderate Hutu
were killed by Hutu extremists. However, there have been claims and
counterclaims regarding atrocities committed against Hutu populations before,
during, and after the genocide.
The document
covers:
1.
The historical
context of the 1994 Rwandan Genocide
2.
Allegations of
mass killings of Hutu by the RPF
3.
Specific
incidents like the Kibeho Massacre and Byumba Stadium killings
4.
Political
assassinations and property seizures
5.
The role of
Uganda and international actors
6.
The controversy
and lack of international accountability
7.
Potential legal
avenues for justice
1. Genocide
Against the Tutsi (1994)
The Rwandan Genocide primarily
targeted the Tutsi ethnic group. Hutu extremist militias, including the
Interahamwe and Impuzamugambi, carried out mass killings over approximately 100
days (April to July 1994). The genocide was triggered by the assassination of
President Juvénal Habyarimana (a Hutu), whose plane was shot down on April 6,
1994.
While the genocide is widely
recognized as being against the Tutsi, moderate Hutus who opposed the extremist
government or refused to participate in the killings were also targeted and
murdered.
2. Mass
Killings of Hutu (Before, During, and After 1994)
Some scholars, journalists, and
organizations have pointed out that large numbers of Hutu civilians were also
killed during and after the genocide, particularly by the Rwandan Patriotic
Front (RPF), the rebel group led by Paul Kagame, which eventually took over the
country and ended the genocide. These killings are often described as reprisals
or war crimes, though some claim they amount to genocide.
A. RPF
Crimes During and After 1994
- As the RPF advanced across Rwanda in
1994, reports emerged of mass killings of Hutu civilians suspected of
being affiliated with the former government or militias.
- In 1996-1997, after the genocide, the
RPF-led Rwandan government pursued Hutu refugees who had fled to the
Democratic Republic of the Congo (then Zaire). Many were civilians, and an
estimated 200,000 to 300,000 may have been killed in attacks on refugee camps.
- The UN Mapping Report (2010) documented
these killings, suggesting they could amount to crimes against humanity or
even genocide. However, no international legal body has officially
recognized these as genocide.
B. The
First and Second Congo Wars (1996–2003)
- After 1994, millions of Hutu refugees
fled to Zaire (now the DRC).
- The Rwandan government, along with its
allies, launched military interventions, targeting both Hutu extremist
militias and civilians.
- The violence led to millions of deaths in
the region, but the exact number of Hutu vs. other victims remains
debated.
3. Is There
Legal Recognition of a Genocide Against the Hutu?
- Unlike the Tutsi genocide, which has been
recognized by the UN, international courts, and most historians, the mass
killings of Hutu have not been officially declared a genocide.
- The Rwandan government under Paul Kagame
strongly denies that a genocide against the Hutu took place, arguing that
RPF actions were military operations against genocidal forces.
- Some researchers, such as Dr. Filip
Reyntjens and Judi Rever, argue that the scale and intent of RPF killings
meet the legal definition of genocide.
- The International Criminal Tribunal for
Rwanda (ICTR) did not prosecute RPF crimes, focusing solely on crimes
committed by Hutu extremists.
4. Specific
Incidents of Mass Killings
Killings of
Refugees in Kibeho (Kibeho Massacre, 1995)
The Kibeho Massacre was a tragic
event that took place on April 22, 1995, in Kibeho, southwestern Rwanda. It
involved the mass killing of internally displaced Hutu refugees by the Rwandan
Patriotic Army (RPA), the military wing of the ruling Rwandan Patriotic Front
(RPF) led by Paul Kagame.
Background:
Why Were There Refugees in Kibeho?
- After the 1994 Rwandan Genocide, in which
Hutu extremists killed an estimated 800,000–1,000,000 Tutsi and moderate
Hutu, the RPF took control of Rwanda in July 1994.
- Many Hutu civilians fled to refugee camps
within Rwanda or into neighboring countries (especially Zaire, now DRC).
These refugees included genuine civilians as well as former government
soldiers and Hutu extremist militias (Interahamwe).
- The Kibeho camp was one of the largest,
holding between 80,000 and 100,000 refugees.
What
Happened in Kibeho?
- The Rwandan government wanted to shut
down the refugee camps, claiming they were being used as bases for Hutu
extremists.
- In April 1995, the Rwandan army (RPA)
surrounded Kibeho and started to forcibly close the camp.
- When refugees refused to leave, violence
broke out.
- On April 22, 1995, Rwandan soldiers
opened fire on unarmed civilians, killing thousands.
Casualty
Estimates
The exact number of deaths
remains disputed:
- Official Rwandan Government Estimate: 338
killed
- UN Estimates: Between 4,000 and 8,000
killed
- Aid Organizations (Médecins Sans
Frontières, Red Cross): Reported at least 5,000+ dead and thousands more
wounded.
- Eyewitness Accounts: Suggest
indiscriminate killings using machine guns, grenades, and machetes.
International
Reactions
- The UN and international NGOs condemned
the massacre but took limited action.
- The Australian peacekeeping forces (part
of the UN mission in Rwanda, UNAMIR) witnessed the killings and provided
some documentation.
- Paul Kagame defended the military's
actions, claiming they were dealing with "insurgents" hiding
among civilians.
- No major prosecutions or international
justice mechanisms addressed the massacre.
Killings of
Hutu in Byumba Stadium (1994)
The Byumba Stadium Massacre is
one of the many mass killings allegedly carried out by the Rwandan Patriotic
Front (RPF) during its military campaign to seize power in Rwanda in 1994. This
event is part of a broader set of reprisal killings against Hutu civilians and
former government soldiers suspected of being involved in the genocide against
the Tutsi.
Background:
RPF's Advance in Byumba
- The Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), led by
Paul Kagame, had been fighting against the Rwandan government since 1990,
initially as a rebel group based in Uganda.
- In April 1994, after the assassination of
President Juvénal Habyarimana, genocide against the Tutsi began. The RPF
launched a full-scale offensive, quickly capturing territory from
government forces (FAR – Forces Armées Rwandaises).
- By mid-April 1994, the RPF took control
of Byumba, a city in northern Rwanda, which became one of its early
strongholds.
Massacre at
Byumba Stadium
- As the RPF took over Byumba, thousands of
Hutu civilians and government soldiers sought refuge in the Byumba
football stadium.
- On or around April 22, 1994, RPF forces
allegedly rounded up the refugees inside the stadium.
- Survivors and human rights reports claim
that the RPF indiscriminately executed many of those inside.
- Methods of killing reportedly included
gunfire, grenades, and machetes.
- Estimates of casualties range from
several hundred to several thousand, though no precise figure has been
officially confirmed.
Why Were
Hutu Targeted?
- While some of the victims may have been
former government soldiers or militia members, many were civilians who had
fled the violence and sought safety.
- The RPF justified the killings as
targeting génocidaires, but survivors and researchers argue that many
innocent Hutu were killed without evidence of wrongdoing.
- The massacre at Byumba was part of a
pattern of RPF violence that continued throughout its advance across
Rwanda.
Mass
Killings of Hutu Refugees in Uganda
While much attention has been
given to the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF)'s mass killings of Hutu refugees in
Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), there is also evidence that
Hutu refugees were targeted and killed in Uganda, particularly during the
1990s.
Uganda played a crucial role in
the rise of the RPF. Paul Kagame and many RPF leaders were part of Yoweri
Museveni's National Resistance Army (NRA) before they invaded Rwanda in 1990.
After the genocide in 1994, many Hutu refugees fled to Uganda, but some of them
were targeted in reprisals, extrajudicial killings, and forced disappearances.
Hutu
Refugee Camps and Targeted Killings
Attacks on
Hutu Refugees in Uganda (1994–1997)
After the RPF took power in
Rwanda in July 1994, thousands of Hutu refugees, including civilians and former
government officials, fled into Uganda. However, instead of being given full
protection as refugees:
- Many Hutu men, including ex-soldiers and
former government officials, were arrested and later disappeared.
- Some Hutu refugees were forcibly returned
to Rwanda, where they were imprisoned or killed by the RPF.
- Reports suggest that Ugandan security
forces, in collaboration with the RPF, carried out assassinations of Hutu
intellectuals, ex-military officers, and political figures in Uganda.
- Some refugees who were suspected of
anti-RPF activities were abducted from refugee settlements and later found
dead.
Kyangwali
and Nakivale Refugee Camps
- Uganda housed Hutu refugees in camps such
as Kyangwali and Nakivale.
- Survivors report that RPF agents
infiltrated these camps, targeting specific individuals.
- Several mysterious disappearances and
killings occurred, with bodies found outside the camps.
Role of the
Ugandan Government
- Uganda had been a key military and
logistical supporter of the RPF during the war in Rwanda (1990–1994).
- Yoweri Museveni's government was closely
allied with Kagame, and intelligence-sharing between the two was common.
- Some reports suggest that Ugandan
intelligence forces helped identify and eliminate "anti-RPF"
elements among the Hutu refugees.
- Hutu refugees in Uganda were often
labeled as "genocidaires," making them vulnerable to arbitrary
arrests, forced disappearances, and extrajudicial executions.
5.
Political Assassinations and Property Seizures
There is credible evidence that
the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), after taking power in 1994, carried out
political assassinations and mass killings of Hutu politicians, businessmen,
and civilians. Many of these killings were not only acts of revenge but also
served to eliminate opposition and seize property from the victims.
Killing of
Hutu Politicians by the RPF
The RPF targeted moderate Hutu
politicians who could have challenged its control or who were seen as a threat.
Some of these individuals had even opposed the genocide but were still
eliminated by the new government. Key examples include:
High-Profile
Hutu Politicians Killed
- Jean-Baptiste Habyalimana – Governor of
Byumba Province, murdered by the RPF in April 1994.
- Félicien Ngango – Vice President of the
Social Democratic Party (PSD), disappeared in 1994.
- Joseph Kavaruganda – President of the
Constitutional Court, killed by RPF agents.
- Landouald Ndasingwa – A moderate Hutu and
leader of the Liberal Party (PL), executed along with his Tutsi wife and
family.
- Many Hutu mayors, judges, and local
leaders were also killed or imprisoned on fabricated charges.
These politicians were either
assassinated outright or falsely accused of genocide and executed
extrajudicially.
The
Elimination of Opposition Parties
- Many Hutu politicians who were not
associated with the genocide but opposed Kagame's rule disappeared or were
assassinated.
- The RPF absorbed or dismantled opposition
parties, creating a one-party state under Kagame's control.
Mass
Killings of Hutu Civilians for Land, Property, and Wealth
Many killings were motivated not
just by politics and revenge but also by the desire to seize land, houses,
businesses, and assets from Hutu victims.
Mass
Displacements and Land Seizures
- After the genocide, thousands of Hutu
families were killed or forced into exile, allowing RPF members and
supporters to take over their homes and businesses.
- In Kigali, Butare, Byumba, and Gisenyi,
many wealthy Hutu disappeared, and their homes were taken over by RPF
soldiers and government officials.
- The Gacaca courts (community tribunals)
were used as a tool to falsely accuse Hutu of genocide, allowing Kagame's
government to imprison them and confiscate their properties.
Targeting
of Businessmen and Landowners
- Wealthy Hutu businessmen and landowners
were accused of "genocidal ideology," arrested, and often never
seen again.
- Survivors and researchers report that
many of these individuals were executed and buried in mass graves.
- The new Rwandan elite, composed mainly of
Kagame's RPF inner circle, took control of these assets, leading to
economic domination by a small group of powerful individuals.
6.
Controversy and Cover-Up
- Unlike the genocide against the Tutsi,
RPF-led massacres have received limited international attention.
- The Rwandan government denies or
downplays these killings, calling them "collateral damage" in a
military campaign.
- Human rights groups, including Human
Rights Watch and independent researchers like Judi Rever and Filip
Reyntjens, have documented such massacres, arguing they could constitute
war crimes or crimes against humanity.
- The UN Mapping Report (2010) on RPF
crimes in Congo also referenced earlier RPF atrocities within Rwanda.
- Western governments, especially the U.S.
and UK, supported Kagame and the RPF, making it difficult to bring
attention to these crimes.
- Journalists and researchers investigating
RPF killings have been threatened, arrested, or forced into exile.
7. Legal
Avenues for Justice
Bringing Rwandan Patriotic Front
(RPF) leaders and officials responsible for war crimes and crimes against
humanity to justice is extremely challenging due to political protection,
international interests, and suppression of evidence. However, several legal
and advocacy strategies could be pursued:
International
Criminal Prosecutions
- Expand the mandate of the International
Criminal Court (ICC)
- The ICC can investigate crimes committed
after 2002 if Rwanda accepts its jurisdiction.
- However, Rwanda is not a member of the
ICC, and Paul Kagame's government has strong international backing.
- A way forward could be an ad-hoc
tribunal for RPF crimes, similar to the International Criminal Tribunal
for Rwanda (ICTR).
- Reopen investigations at the United
Nations (UN)
- The UN Mapping Report (2010) documented
mass killings of Hutu refugees in the Democratic Republic of the Congo
(DRC) by the RPF, calling them potential crimes of genocide.
- Lobbying UN member states to push for an
independent tribunal could be an option.
- Seek Prosecutions Under Universal
Jurisdiction
- Countries like Belgium, France, Spain,
and Germany have prosecuted Rwandan genocide suspects under universal
jurisdiction laws.
- Cases could be filed in these countries
against RPF officials accused of crimes, particularly those living
abroad.
African
Union (AU) and Regional Courts
- The African Court on Human and Peoples'
Rights (ACHPR) has jurisdiction over crimes committed by state actors.
- Although Kagame's government influences
AU politics, legal cases could be pursued through independent African
human rights groups.
Organizations
That Could Help Pursue Justice:
- Public International Law & Policy
Group (PILPG): A global pro bono law firm with expertise in war crimes
prosecution.
- Civitas Maxima: Dedicated to documenting
mass crimes and seeking justice for victims.
- Humanitarian Law Center (HLC): Works on
documenting human rights violations and pursuing justice for war crimes.
- Human Rights Watch (HRW): Has a history
of reporting on human rights abuses in Rwanda, including those committed
by the RPF.
- International Residual Mechanism for
Criminal Tribunals (IRMCT): Successor to the ICTR that continues to handle
residual functions.
8.
Conclusion: A Complex Legacy
While the RPF played a crucial
role in ending the genocide against the Tutsi, these reports and testimonies
suggest a need for a more nuanced understanding of the post-genocide period.
The mass killings, political assassinations, and economic dispossession of Hutu
by the RPF remain largely unacknowledged. Many researchers argue that the scale
and intent of RPF crimes could qualify as genocide, yet no international action
has been taken. Addressing these allegations is essential for comprehensive
reconciliation and justice in Rwanda.
References:
- Des Forges, Alison. Leave None to Tell
the Story: Genocide in Rwanda. Human Rights Watch, 1999.
- United Nations Security Council. Report
of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR). 1999.
- United Nations High Commissioner for
Human Rights. Democratic Republic of the Congo, 1993-2003: UN Mapping
Report. 2010.
- Reyntjens, Filip. Political Governance
in Post-Genocide Rwanda. Cambridge University Press, 2013.
- Médecins Sans Frontières. Kibeho: A
Genocide That the World Chose to Ignore. 1995.
- United Nations Assistance Mission for
Rwanda (UNAMIR) reports, 1995.
- Rever, Judi. In Praise of Blood:
Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front. Random House Canada, 2018.
- Human Rights Watch reports on Byumba
Massacre, 1994.
- Amnesty International. Rwanda:
Political Assassinations and Enforced Disappearances. 1997.
- Reyntjens, Filip. Rwanda, Ten Years
On: From Genocide to Dictatorship. African Affairs, 2004.
- Human Rights Watch. Uganda: Refugees
at Risk in Border Regions. 1996.
- African Rights. Refugees in Uganda: A
Forgotten People. 1997.
- United
Nations. International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda: A Selective
Approach to Justice? 2004.
- Schabas,
William A. Genocide in International Law: The Crimes of Crimes.
Cambridge University Press, 2009.
- International
Federation for Human Rights (FIDH). Accountability for Crimes in
Rwanda: A Roadmap for Justice. 2015.
- African
Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights. Human Rights Violations in
Post-Genocide Rwanda. 2012.Lemarchand, René. The Dynamics of
Violence in Central Africa. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2009.
- Prunier,
Gérard. Africa’s World War: Congo, the Rwandan Genocide, and the Making
of a Continental Catastrophe. Oxford University Press, 2009.
